Criminal Reference Check: A Guide for UK Employers and Applicants

Criminal Reference Checks in the UK: What Employers and Applicants Need to Know

The phrase “criminal reference check” is often used to describe a check of someone’s criminal record during recruitment. In the UK, however, it is not the name of one single, standard check. The type of check available depends on the role, the applicant’s location and the legal rules that apply.

Employers and applicants should understand what information a check can reveal, when it can be requested and how the information may be used.

What is a criminal reference check?

A criminal record check is a search of relevant criminal-record information, usually carried out through an official disclosure service. It may form part of an employer’s recruitment process, alongside references, identity checks and verification of qualifications.

A standard employment reference is different. It is information provided by a previous employer or another referee, and does not automatically include a search of an applicant’s criminal record.

“Criminal reference check” is not a universal UK legal term. If an organisation uses the phrase, applicants can ask which check it means, what information it will cover and why it is required for the role.

Types of criminal record check

The level of check an employer can request depends on the work involved. In general, higher-level checks are only available for roles that meet specific legal eligibility criteria.

  • Basic check: Shows unspent convictions and conditional cautions, subject to the rules of the relevant disclosure service. A basic check may be available for a wider range of roles.
  • Standard check: May show spent and unspent convictions and cautions recorded on the relevant police records, subject to filtering rules. It is only available for eligible roles.
  • Enhanced check: Includes the information available on a standard check and may include relevant information held by local police. It is restricted to eligible roles.
  • Enhanced check with a barred-list check: For certain eligible roles involving regulated activity, this can also check whether the person is barred from working with children or adults.

Not every employer can request a standard or enhanced check. The role must meet the legal requirements for that level of disclosure. An employer should not request a higher-level check simply because it would prefer more information.

Which service applies?

Disclosure arrangements differ across the UK. The appropriate service generally depends on where the role is based:

  • England and Wales: The Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) provides criminal record checks.
  • Scotland: Disclosure Scotland provides disclosures, including checks linked to the Protecting Vulnerable Groups (PVG) scheme.
  • Northern Ireland: AccessNI provides criminal record checks.

Applicants should follow the process specified by the employer or relevant disclosure service. The rules and names of checks are not identical across all three jurisdictions.

Spent convictions and filtering

Some convictions and cautions become “spent” after a rehabilitation period. Whether a record is spent depends on factors such as the disposal or sentence and the applicable legislation. A spent conviction does not necessarily appear on every type of check.

Filtering rules may also mean that certain older or less serious convictions and cautions are not disclosed on standard or enhanced checks. The rules are detailed and can change, so anyone unsure about their own record should seek guidance from the relevant disclosure service or a qualified adviser.

Applicants should answer recruitment questions accurately and within the scope of what the employer is legally entitled to ask. Where a question concerns criminal records, check whether it relates to unspent convictions only or to information that may lawfully be disclosed for that particular role.

How employers should use the information

A criminal record should not automatically prevent someone from getting a job. Employers should consider whether disclosed information is relevant to the role, how long ago the matter occurred, its seriousness and the circumstances. They should also apply their policy consistently and give the applicant a fair opportunity to explain any relevant information.

Employers must handle criminal-record information carefully. They should have a lawful basis for processing it, restrict access to people who need it and store or dispose of it securely. Data protection requirements apply, including when information is obtained through an official check.

What applicants can expect

If a criminal record check is required, an applicant can ask:

  • which type of check is being requested;
  • why the role is eligible for that level of check;
  • which disclosure service will carry it out;
  • how the information will be used, stored and retained; and
  • who to contact if information appears to be inaccurate.

Applicants should provide the information and identity documents requested through the official process. If a check contains information they believe is incorrect, they should contact the relevant disclosure service promptly to ask about its dispute or correction procedure.

In summary

A “criminal reference check” usually means a criminal record check used during recruitment, but it is important to confirm exactly what is meant. The appropriate check depends on the role and the UK jurisdiction, and more detailed checks are restricted to legally eligible work. Employers should use results fairly and securely, while applicants should understand what they are being asked to disclose and how the information will be handled.

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Check the current guidance from DBS, Disclosure Scotland or AccessNI for rules that apply to a particular role or application.

 

9 Essential Tips for Fair and Compliant Criminal Record Checks

  1. Obtain the applicant’s informed consent first.
  2. Explain why the check is relevant to the role.
  3. Use a check level permitted for the position.
  4. Check identity details carefully.
  5. Use an authorised DBS checking route where required.
  6. Consider spent convictions under applicable rules.
  7. Assess any relevant disclosure fairly and individually.
  8. Keep results confidential and secure.
  9. Follow data protection and retention requirements.

Before carrying out a criminal record check, explain to the applicant why it is needed, what type of check will be requested and how the information will be used and stored. Obtain their informed consent and give them the opportunity to ask questions. Make sure the check is appropriate and legally permitted for the role; consent alone does not make an otherwise ineligible check lawful.

Explain why the check is relevant to the role.

Explain clearly why a criminal record check is relevant to the specific role. For example, the position may involve working with children or vulnerable adults, handling sensitive information, managing money or entering people’s homes. The check should be proportionate to the responsibilities involved and permitted by law; employers should not request a higher-level check unless the role is eligible for it.

Use a check level permitted for the position.

Choose a criminal record check level that is legally permitted for the position. Basic checks are available for a wider range of roles, while standard and enhanced checks are restricted to work that meets specific eligibility criteria. Before requesting a check, confirm that the role qualifies for that level and explain to the applicant why it is needed. This helps ensure the process is proportionate and compliant with the rules.

Check identity details carefully.

Check identity details carefully. Before requesting or completing a criminal record check, make sure the applicant’s full name, date of birth and address history are accurate and consistent with their identity documents. Even small errors can cause delays or lead to information being matched to the wrong person. If anything does not match, clarify it through the appropriate official process rather than making assumptions.

Use an authorised DBS checking route where required.

Where a role is eligible for a DBS check, use the appropriate authorised route for the level of check required. Standard and Enhanced checks must be requested through an organisation registered with the DBS or an approved umbrella body; applicants cannot usually apply for these checks directly. Confirm that the role meets the legal eligibility criteria, and use the relevant disclosure service in Scotland or Northern Ireland where applicable.

Consider spent convictions under applicable rules.

When considering a criminal reference check, remember that convictions may become spent after a rehabilitation period, depending on the sentence and the rules that apply. Spent convictions are not necessarily disclosed on every type of check, and filtering rules may also apply. Employers should only ask for or consider information they are legally entitled to receive for the role, while applicants should check the relevant disclosure guidance if they are unsure what they need to declare.

Assess any relevant disclosure fairly and individually.

When a criminal record check reveals relevant information, assess it fairly and on an individual basis rather than treating it as an automatic reason to reject an applicant. Consider the nature and seriousness of the offence, how long ago it occurred, its relevance to the role and any explanation or evidence the applicant provides. Apply the same approach consistently, respect the applicant’s privacy and give them a reasonable opportunity to discuss the disclosure before making a decision.

Keep results confidential and secure.

Criminal record check results contain sensitive personal information, so they should be kept confidential and stored securely. Limit access to people who genuinely need the information, use it only for the purpose it was obtained for, and follow data protection requirements for retention and disposal. Never share results casually or disclose them to anyone without proper authority.

Follow data protection and retention requirements.

Follow data protection and retention requirements when handling criminal record information. Collect only what is necessary for a lawful purpose, restrict access to authorised staff and store records securely. Keep the information only for as long as there is a clear business or legal need, then delete or destroy it securely in line with your retention policy and applicable data protection law.